AU2007201496B2 - Water heater burner clogging detection and shutdown system with associated burner apparatus - Google Patents

Description

S&F Ref: 803960

AUSTRALIA

PATENTS ACT 1990 COMPLETE SPECIFICATION FOR A STANDARD PATENT Name and Address of Applicant Actual Inventor(s): Address for Service: Invention Title: Rheem Manufacturing Company, of 500 Northpark Town Center 1100 Abemathy Road, Suite 1400, Atlanta, Georgia, 30328, United States of America William J. Hall Gary A. Elder Jacob A. Peart Thomas C. Hawkins Spruson Ferguson St Martins Tower Level 31 Market Street Sydney NSW 2000 (CCN 3710000177) Water heater burner clogging detection and shutdown system with associated burner apparatus The following statement is a full description of this invention, including the best method of performing it known to me/us:- 5845c(742147_1) WATER HEATER BURNER CLOGGING DETECTION AND SHUTDOWN SYSTEM WITH ASSOCIATED BURNER APPARATUS SCROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION This application is related to copending U.S. application serial no. 10/991,804 (US Patent No. 7,162,980) filed on November 18, 2004, such copending application being hereby incorporated in its entirety herein by reference.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION The present invention generally relates to fuel-fired heating apparatus and, in a representatively illustrated embodiment thereof, more particularly provides a fuel-fired water heater having incorporated therein a burner clogging detection and shutdown system.

Fuel-fired water heaters typically operate in locations (such as, for example, attics, closets, basements, sheds, etc.) which are not regularly cleaned, and have ambient air containing particulate matter such as lint, dirt and/or oil. It is this contaminant-laden air which is delivered to the water heater as combustion air for its burner system. The airborne particulate matter in such combustion air can, over time, clog the water heater's burner and undesirably increase its production of carbon monoxide.

In view of this it would be desirable to provide a fuel-fired water heater with a burner clogging detection system which could monitor the degree of burner clogging caused by airborne particulate matter ingested by the burner and prevent further burner combustion in response to the detection of a predetermined level of burner clogging.

OBJECT OF THE INVENTION It is the object of the present invention to overcome or ameliorate one or more of the disadvantages of the prior art, or at least to provide a useful alternative.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION In a first aspect, the present invention provides a fuel-fired heating apparatus comprising: a combustion chamber; a main fuel burner disposed in said combustion chamber and having: a hollow body with a perforate section cloggable by particulate matter entrained in combustion air being delivered to the interior of said hollow body during -1- 926797 1 ITCW firing of said main fuel burner, said hollow body having a generally vertical side wall extending transversely to a generally vertical end wall, and an air-receiving structure coupled to said hollow body at an end thereof opposite from said generally vertical end wall, and having an interior communicating with the interior of said hollow body, and defining a passage for flowing primary combustion air into the interior of said hollow body from outside of said combustion chamber, said air-receiving structure having a generally vertical side wall; a pilot fuel burner disposed in said combustion chamber and being operative to generate a pilot flame useable to ignite said main fuel burner, said pilot fuel burner being mounted on one of said generally vertical side wall of said hollow body, said generally vertical end wall of said hollow body, and said generally vertical side wall of said air-receiving structure and having: an air inlet portion extending into the interior of said main fuel burner and having an air inlet opening operative to receive combustion air from within said interior of said main fuel burner, and a cloggable perforate structure interposed in the path of combustion air being received by said air inlet opening; and a shutdown system for terminating combustion in said combustion chamber prior to said perforate section of said hollow body becoming clogged to a predetermined degree, said shutdown system being operative to monitor the condition of said pilot flame and terminate combustion within said combustion chamber when said condition becomes indicative of a predetermined degree of clogging of said cloggable perforate structure of said pilot fuel burner.

In a second aspect, the present invention provides a fuel burner apparatus operatively positionable in the combustion chamber of a fuel-fired heating appliance, comprising: a radiant main fuel burner having a hollow body with a perforate top wall section cloggable by particulate matter entrained in combustion air being delivered to the interior of said hollow body during firing of said radiant main fuel burner, said hollow body having a side wall and an end wall extending downwardly from said top wall section, and an air-receiving structure coupled to said hollow body opposite said end wall thereof and having an interior communicating with the interior of said body for flowing primary combustion air into the interior of said hollow body directly from outside the combustion chamber, and a side wall generally parallel to said side wall of said hollow body; and -la- 926797 1:TCW a pilot fuel burner operative to generate a pilot flame useable to ignite said radiant fuel burner, and an air inlet portion extending from said pilot fuel burner into the interior of said radiant main fuel burner and having an air inlet opening operative to receive combustion air from within the interior of said main radiant fuel burner, and a cloggable perforate structure interposed within the path of combustion air being received by said air inlet opening, said cloggable perforate structure, relative to said perforate cloggable top wall section of said hollow body, being more readily cloggable by particulate matter in combustion air within the interior of said main radiant fuel burner, said pilot fuel burner being externally mounted on one of said end wall of said hollow body, said side wall of said hollow body, and said side wall of said air-receiving structure.

In carrying out principles of the present invention, in accordance with a representatively illustrated embodiment thereof, fuel-fired heating apparatus is provided which has a combustion chamber in which a first fuel burner is disposed, the first fuel burner being operative to create a flame in the combustion chamber and being cloggable by particulate matter entrained in primary -Ib- 926797 1 TCW combustion air delivered thereto during firing thereof A second fuel burner is operative to create a flame and is also cloggable by particulate matter entrained in primary combustion air delivered thereto during firing thereof.

The representatively illustrated fuel-fired heating apparatus also has an air supply system for supplying primary combustion air from outside the combustion chamber to the first and second fuel burners without exposing the supplied primary combustion air to the interior of the combustion chamber on its way to the first and second fuel burners.

_A shutdown system is also incorporated into the fuel-fired heating apparatus for N monitoring the condition of the second fuel burner flame and terminating combustion within the combustion chamber when the second burner flame condition is indicative of a predetermined N degree of clogging of the second fuel burner. Since all of the primary combustion air supplied to the first and second burners comes from outside the combustion chamber via a path isolated from the interior of the combustion chamber, the degree of particulate matter clogging of the second burner, representatively a pilot burner located within the combustion chamber and operative to ignite the first or main burner, is directly indicative of the degree of particulate matter clogging of the main burner, representatively a radiant fuel burner.

Illustratively, the fuel-fired heating apparatus is a gas-fired water heater provided with a fuel supply system for delivering fuel, from a source thereof, to the main and pilot burners, the fuel supply system including a fuel supply valve, and the shutdown system is operative to cause closure of the fuel valve in response to detecting the change in condition in the pilot burner flame. The shutdown system preferably includes a thermocouple positioned to be impinged upon by the pilot burner flame and operatively coupled to the fuel valve. Other methods of terminating water heater combustion, such as terminating combustion air flow to the burners, could alternatively be employed if desired.

In an illustrated specific structural embodiment thereof, the fuel-fired water heater has a radiant main burner disposed in its combustion chamber and having a hollow body with a perforate flame-holding outer wall section cloggable by particulate matter entrained in combustion air being delivered to the main burner during firing thereof. An air-receiving plenum structure is coupled to the hollow body and has an interior communicating with the interior of the hollow body, and a wall structure defining a passage for flowing primary Scombustion air into the plenum, from outside of the combustion chamber, for delivery from within the plenum to the interior of the hollow body.

A pilot fuel burner is disposed in the combustion chamber externally of the main fuel burner and is operative to generate a pilot flame useable to ignite the main fuel burner. The pilot burner has an air inlet portion extending into the plenum and having an air inlet opening disposed within the plenum for receiving combustion air delivered thereto via the aforementioned passage, and a cloggable perforate structure, representatively of a metal wire mesh construction, Sinterposed in the path of combustion air being received by the inlet opening.

The pilot burner may be mounted in a variety of locations on the overall main burner/air- Sreceiving plenum structure. For example, the pilot fuel burner may be mounted on the top or side of the air-receiving plenum structure with the pilot fuel burner air inlet portion extending into the interior of the air-receiving plenum structure. Alternatively, the pilot fuel burner may be mounted on a side or end of the hollow main fuel burner body with the pilot burner air inlet portion extending into the interior of the hollow main burner body.

The shutdown system operates to terminate combustion in the combustion chamber prior to the outer wall section of the main fuel burner becoming clogged to a predetermined degree, the shutdown system being operative to monitor the condition of the pilot fuel burner flame and terminate combustion within the combustion chamber when the condition becomes indicative of a predetermined degree of clogging of the cloggable perforate structure of the pilot fuel burner.

From a broad perspective, the invention provides a method of operating a fuel-fired heating appliance having a first fuel burner disposed within a combustion chamber, the method comprising the steps of providing a second fuel burner; supplying to the first and second fuel burners all of the primary combustion air utilized thereby during firing thereof from outside the combustion chamber in a manner isolating the supplied primary combustion air from exposure to the interior of the combustion chamber; detecting clogging of the second fuel burner caused by particulate matter entrained in primary combustion air being supplied thereto; and preventing further combustion within the combustion chamber in response to detecting a predetermined degree of clogging of the second fuel burner.

t BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS O o FIG. 1 is a schematic cross-sectional view through a lower end portion of a representative 4 fuel-fired water heater incorporating therein a specially designed burner clogging detection and shutdown system embodying principles of the present invention; o FIG. 2 is an enlarged scale bottom end view of an air supply tube portion of a sensor/pilot structure of the system taken along line 2-2 of FIG. 1; SFIG. 3 is an enlarged scale side elevational view of the FIG. 1 radiant fuel burner representatively used in the water heater and illustrates a first alternate location of the 0 C sensor/pilot structure on the burner inlet plenum box; o FIG. 4 is an enlarged scale side elevational view of the burner and illustrates a second 0 alternate location of the sensor/pilot structure on the burner body; and FIG. 5 is an enlarged scale end elevational view of the burner and illustrates a third alternate location of the sensor/pilot structure on the burner body.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION Schematically illustrated in FIG. 1 in cross-sectional form is a lower end portion of a fuel-fired heating appliance, representatively a gas-fired water heater 10, embodying principles of the present invention. While the heating appliance is representatively a water heater, it could alternatively be a different type of fuel-fired heating appliance, such as, for example, a fuel-fired boiler or air heating furnace without departing from principles of the present invention.

Water heater 10 is shown resting on a horizontal support surface such as floor 12 and includes a cylindrical, vertically extending insulated metal tank 14 in which a quantity of pressurized heated water 16 is stored for on-demand delivery in the usual manner to plumbing fixtures (not shown) such as sinks, showers, dishwashers and the like. The bottom wall of the tank 14 defines the top wall 18 of a combustion chamber 20 that underlies the tank 14.

Extending upwardly from the wall 18, through the water 16, is a flue pipe 22 communicating with the interior of the combustion chamber A main gas burner 24, representatively a radiant burner, is disposed within the interior of the combustion chamber 20. Other types of fuel burners could alternatively be utilized without departing from principles of the present invention. Firing of the burner 24 creates hot Scombustion products 26 that pass upwardly through the flue pipe 22 and transfer combustion O heat to the stored water 16.

SRadiant burner 24 has a horizontally elongated hollow body 28 with a top perforate Sflame-holding wall section 30 which is illustratively of a metal wire mesh construction. A right end wall 32 of the burner body 28 has an air inlet opening 34 therein which communicates the interior of the burner body 28 with the interior of an air inlet plenum box 36 projecting horizontally outwardly from the right end wall 32 of the burner body 28. A primary combustion air inlet duct 38, having an open right or inlet end 40, communicates with the interior of the inlet C plenum box 36 and extends outwardly through the vertical outer side wall 42 of the combustion chamber As subsequently described herein, during firing of the burner 24, primary combustion air 44 is delivered to the burner 24 via duct 38 and the plenum 36, and is mixed with fuel gas delivered to the burner 24 through a main burner fuel line 46 interconnected between the burner 24 and a conventional thermostatic gas supply valve 48 externally mounted on the water heater as shown and monitoring the temperature of the stored heated water 16. Burning of the fuel/air mixture by the burner 24 during firing thereof creates within the combustion chamber the aforementioned hot combustion products 26.

Over time, the mesh wall section 30 of the main fuel burner 24 may begin to become clogged with particulate matter (such as lint, dirt and/or oil) entrained in the incoming primary combustion air 44. This can undesirably increase the level of carbon monoxide generated by the firing of the water heater 10. In order to prevent the water heater 10 from being fired after the burner 24 has become clogged to an undesirable degree, the present invention provides a specially designed burner clogging detection and shutdown system 50 which will now be described.

System 50 includes a pilot fuel burner 52 used as a main burner clogging detector, and a thermocouple 54 interconnected to the gas valve 48 by electrical leads 56 and 58. Pilot burner 52 is representatively disposed within the combustion chamber 20 externally of the main burner 24, but could alternatively be positioned outside of the combustion chamber.

The pilot fuel burner 52 is used to selectively ignite the main fuel burner 24 and has a body 60 to which are connected a pilot burner fuel line 62 coupled to the gas supply valve 48, an air inlet tube 64 projecting downwardly into the plenum box 36 and having an open bottom inlet Send covered by a perforate cloggable member 66 representatively of a metal wire screen construction (see FIG. and an air/fuel mixture tube 68 having an open outer or left end at 4 which a pilot flame 70 is created during firing of the pilot burner 52. As illustrated in FIG. I, the S thermocouple 54 is positioned to be impinged upon, and be heated by, the pilot flame During firing of the water heater 10, primary combustion air 44 is drawn into the open end 40 of the air inlet duct 38 and into the main burner inlet plenum box 36. A first portion 44a of this incoming primary combustion air 44 enters the hollow main burner body 28 via its end opening 34 and is used to support main burner combustion. At the same time, a second portion 44b of the incoming primary combustion air 44 flows upwardly through the screen 66 and into the pilot burner body 60 via the air inlet tube 64 to support pilot burner combustion resulting in N the illustrated pilot flame If the incoming primary combustion air 44 from outside the combustion chamber (which serves both the main burner 24 and the pilot burner 52) contains particulate material (such as lint, dirt, and/or oil) which can clog the screen portion 30 of the main burner 24, such particulate material will (after time) clog the screen 66 on the inlet end of the pilot air intake tube 64. This progressive clogging of the inlet screen 66 changes the pattern of the pilot flame (which also serves as a sensor flame) in a manner such that the pilot flame heat received by the thermocouple 54 is reduced. When this thermocouple-received heat reduction is sufficiently large, the electrical output of the thermocouple 54 (via the electrical leads 56,58) becomes too small to hold its associated gas valve 48 open, and the gas valve 48 returns to its normally closed position, thereby terminating fuel gas flow to both the main and pilot burners 24,52 and stopping further combustion in the combustion chamber. Instead of using the reduced thermocouple electrical output to terminate fuel flow to the burners 24 and 52, it could be used in another manner to terminate combustion in the combustion chamber 20 such as, for example, preventing further primary combustion air flow to the burners.

As can be seen, because all of the primary combustion air supplied to the main and pilot burners 24,52 comes from outside of the combustion chamber 20 via a flow path which is isolated from contact with the interior of the combustion chamber 20, the particulate matter clogging of the pilot burner air inlet screen 66, which alters the pilot flame condition and triggers combustion shutdown, is directly indicative of clogging of the main burner 24. Accordingly, by setting the thermocouple 54 to cause gas valve closure in response to the detection of a predetermined degree of clogging of the pilot burner air inlet screen 66, operation of the water heater 10 may be shut down prior to the main burner 24 becoming clogged with airborne particulate matter to a degree creating an unacceptably high level of carbon monoxide during firing of the water heater The pilot burner 52 (see FIG. I) has been representatively illustrated as being externally mounted on the top side of the overall combustion air-receiving structure 36,38, with the pilot burner air inlet tube 64 extending inwardly into the interior of such air-receiving structure 36,38.

However, if desired, the pilot burner 52 may be mounted on a variety of alternate locations on the overall main fuel burner structure 24 without departing from principles of the present invention.

For example, as depicted in FIG. 3, instead of mounting the pilot burner 52 on the top side of the air inlet plenum box 36 (as shown in FIG. the pilot burner 52 may be externally mounted on a vertical side wall 71 of the air inlet plenum box 36, with the pilot burner air inlet tube 64 extending into the interior of the air inlet plenum box 36. As shown in FIG. 4, the pilot burner 52 may alternatively be mounted externally on a vertical side wall 72 of the hollow body 28 of the fuel burner 24, with the pilot burner air inlet tube 64 extending into the interior of the hollow body 28. Additionally, as shown in FIG. 5, the pilot burner 52 may alternatively be mounted externally on an end wall 74 of the hollow body 28 opposite the air-receiving structure 36,38, with the pilot burner air inlet tube 64 extending into the interior of the hollow body 28.

The foregoing detailed description is to be clearly understood as being given by way of illustration and example only, the spirit and scope of the present invention being limited solely by the appended claims.

Claims (18)

1. Fuel-fired heating apparatus comprising: a combustion chamber; a main fuel burner disposed in said combustion chamber and having: a hollow body with a perforate section cloggable by particulate matter entrained in combustion air being delivered to the interior of said hollow body during firing of said main fuel burner, said hollow body having a generally vertical side wall extending transversely to a generally vertical end wall, and an air-receiving structure coupled to said hollow body at an end thereof to opposite from said generally vertical end wall, and having an interior communicating with the interior of said hollow body, and defining a passage for flowing primary combustion air into the interior of said hollow body from outside of said combustion chamber, said air-receiving structure having a generally vertical side wall; a pilot fuel burner disposed in said combustion chamber and being operative to generate a pilot flame useable to ignite said main fuel burner, said pilot fuel burner being mounted on one of said generally vertical side wall of said hollow body, said generally vertical end wall of said hollow body, and said generally vertical side wall of said air-receiving structure and having: an air inlet portion extending into the interior of said main fuel burner and having an air inlet opening operative to receive combustion air from within said interior of said main fuel burner, and a cloggable perforate structure interposed in the path of combustion air being received by said air inlet opening; and a shutdown system for terminating combustion in said combustion chamber prior to said perforate section of said hollow body becoming clogged to a predetermined degree, said shutdown system being operative to monitor the condition of said pilot flame and terminate combustion within said combustion chamber when said condition becomes indicative of a predetermined degree of clogging of said cloggable perforate structure of said pilot fuel burner.

2. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: said fuel-fired heating apparatus further comprises a fuel supply system for delivering fuel, from a source thereof, to said main and pilot fuel burners, said fuel supply system including a fuel valve, and said shutdown system is operative to close said fuel valve in response to detecting said condition of said pilot burner flame. -8- 926797 I:TCW

3. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 2 wherein: said shutdown system includes a thermocouple positioned to be impinged upon Sby said pilot burner flame and operatively coupled to said fuel valve.

4. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: said fuel-fired heating apparatus is a fuel-fired water heater.

The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 4 wherein: IDsaid fuel-fired water heater is a gas fired water heater.

6. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim I wherein: said main fuel burner is a radiant burner.

7. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: Ssaid pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on said generally vertical end wall of said hollow body of said main fuel burner, and said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extends into the interior of said hollow body of said main fuel burner.

8. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on said generally vertical side wall of said hollow body with said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extending into the interior of said hollow body of said main fuel burner.

9. The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is mounted on said generally vertical side wall of said air-receiving structure with said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extending into the interior of said air-receiving structure.

The fuel-fired heating apparatus of Claim 1 wherein: said cloggable perforate section of said hollow body of said main fuel burner is of a metal mesh material, and said cloggable perforate structure of said pilot fuel burner is of a metal mesh material having a finer mesh size than the mesh size of said cloggable perforate section of said hollow body of said main fuel burner.

11. Fuel burner apparatus operatively positionable in the combustion chamber of a fuel-fired heating appliance, comprising: a radiant main fuel burner having a hollow body with a perforate top wall section cloggable by particulate matter entrained in combustion air being delivered to the interior of said hollow body during firing of said radiant main fuel burner, said hollow body having a side wall and an end wall extending downwardly from said top wall section, and an air-receiving structure coupled to said hollow body opposite said end wall thereof and -9- 926797 I 'I'CW having an interior communicating with the interior of said body for flowing primary combustion air into the interior of said hollow body directly from outside the combustion chamber, and a side wall generally parallel to said side wall of said hollow body; and a pilot fuel burner operative to generate a pilot flame useable to ignite said radiant fuel burner, and an air inlet portion extending from said pilot fuel burner into the interior of said radiant main fuel burner and having an air inlet opening operative to receive combustion air from within the interior of said main radiant fuel burner, and a cloggable perforate structure interposed within the path of combustion air being received by said air inlet opening, said cloggable perforate structure, relative to said perforate 0io cloggable top wall section of said hollow body, being more readily cloggable by particulate matter in combustion air within the interior of said main radiant fuel burner, said pilot fuel burner being externally mounted on one of said end wall of said hollow body, said side wall of said hollow body, and said side wall of said air-receiving structure.

12. The fuel burner apparatus of Claim 1 I wherein: Is said perforate top wall section of said hollow body and said cloggable perforate structure are each of a metal mesh construction, with the metal mesh of said cloggable perforate structure being of a finer mesh size than the mesh size of said perforate top wall section of said hollow body.

13. The fuel burner apparatus of Claim 1 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on a top side portion of said air-receiving structure, and said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extends into the interior of said air-receiving structure.

14. The fuel burner apparatus of Claim 1 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on said side wall of said air-receiving structure, and said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extends into the interior of said air-receiving structure.

The fuel burner apparatus of Claim 1 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on said side wall of said hollow body, and said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extends into the interior of said hollow body.

16. The fuel burner apparatus of Claim 1 1 wherein: said pilot fuel burner is externally mounted on said end wall of said hollow body, and said air inlet portion of said pilot fuel burner extends into the interior of said hollow body. 926797 I ICW

17. A fuel-fired heating apparatus substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one embodiment, as that embodiment is shown in the accompanying drawings.

18. A fuel burner apparatus operatively positionable in the combustion chamber of a fuel-fired heating appliance, said fuel burner apparatus substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one embodiment, as that embodiment is shown in the accompanying drawings. Dated 10 September, 2007 Rheem Manufacturing Company 1o Patent Attorneys for the Applicant/Nominated Person SPRUSON FERGUSON -11- 926797 I TCW