AU668758B2 - Process for treating and sizing paper substrates - Google Patents

Description

OPI DATE 05/10/93 APPLN. ID 48079/93 1 i 11 AOJP DATE 09/12/93 PCT NUMBER PCT/EP93/00229 11111111 111ll l 111111111111111I AU9348079

I)

(51) International Patent Classification 5 International Publication Number: WO 93/18228 D21H 23/50, 19/24 Al (43) International Publication Date: 16 September 1993 (16.09.93) (21) International Application Number: PCT/EP93/00229 (74) Agents: SWINNEN. Anne. Marie et al.; ICI Group Patents Services Department. P.O. Box 6. Shire Park. Be- (22) International Filing Date: 1 February 1993 (01.02.93) ssemer Road, Welwyn Garden City. Hertfordshire AL7 IHD (GB).

Priority data: 07/844,346 2 March 1992 (02.03.92) US (81) Designated States: AU. CA, FI, JP, NZ, European patent (AT, BE, CH, DE, DK, ES, FR. GB, GR. IE, IT, LU, MC, NL, PT, SE).

(71) Applicant: IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES PLC [GB/GB]; Imperial Chemical House, Millbank, London SWIP 3JF Published With international search report.

(72) Inventors: COLEMAN, Paul, David 94 Woodway Drive, West Deptford, NJ 08066 ROBERTSON, John, Russell 59 Paul Lane, Glenn Mills, PA 19342 (54)Title: PROCESS FOR TREATING AND SIZING PAPER SUBSTRATES (57) Abstract Process for strengthening and sizing paper with isocyanate characterized in that the isocyanate does not contain water and the isocyanate is applied to the paper by means of a linear electrostatic spraying device. The process is an efficient way to apply water-free isocyanate to paper at low percentage levels in an environmentally safe manner.

ii

II

WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 PROCESS FOR TREATING AND SIZING PAPER SUBSTRATES Field of Invention The present invention is concerned with a process for treating and sizing paper substrates with an isocyanate. In particular, the present invention is concerned with a process for strengthening and sizing paper with an isocyanate characterized in that the isocyanate does not contain water and is applied to paper by means of an electrostatic spraying device.

Background of Invention The treatment of paper with isocyanates has been disclosed. For example, a process for treating paper with isocyanates is disclosed in EP 140537.

In United States Patent No. 4,505,778, a process for applying a size of an aqueous emulsion of an aromatic isocyanate to a wet paper web is disclosed.

However, neither patent discloses a process in which isocyanates are electrostatically sprayed onto paper.

Isocyanates emulsified with water have been applied to paper using a size press and unemulsified isocyanates have been applied using a rotogravure coating machine. When conventional means of spraying isocyanates are used, they are characterized by low transfer efficiencies. As a result, significant amounts of isocyanate are released into the atmosphere, thereby creating potential health problems.

In addition, when the isocyanate that is applied to paper is not sprayed, solvent diluted, or emulsified, it is very difficult to apply the isocyanate at levels below 5 to 10 percent by weight based upon SUBSTITUTE SHEET WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 the weight of the paper. Lower isocyanate levels can be achieved by using emulsified isocyanates.

However, pot life problems with the isocyanate can arise when the isocyanates are emulsified because the water begins to react with the isocyanate groups. Furthermore, depending upon when in the process the emulsion is added, it can result in additional drying requirements. There is therefore a need for a process for efficiently applying isocyanates'to paper substrates at levels below 5 percent by weight based upon the weight of the paper substrates and a process that does not utilize emulsified isocyanates, although emulsifiable isocyanates Smay be used.

Surprisingly it has been found that these needs can be met by using an electrostatic spraying device to apply isocyanates to paper. By using this electrostatic spraying device, transfer efficiencies above 90 percent can be achieved and the isocyanate can easily be applied to paper substrates at levels well below 5 percent by weight. The amount of isocyanate needed according to the invention can be as low as 0.5 g/m 2 However, in commercial production settings, the amount of isocyanate needed is generally about 1.0 to 1.5 g/m 2 Electrostatic spraying devices as such are known. See, for example, United States Patent Nos.

4854506 and 4846407 and EPA-193348. The electrostatic spraying of various polymeric materials onto paper has also been disclosed in United States Patent Nos. 3930614, 4609686 and 4837057.

However, none of these patents disclose the electrostatic spraying of isocyanates onto paper.

It is an object of this invention to provide a means for efficiently applying an isocyanate to a paper substrate.

-2- SUBSTITUTE SHEET i- I r- ~I WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 it is a f-urther object to provide amas r improving the crush strength, water resista and wet strength of paper products.

It is yet another object to ovide a means of applying a uniform coating isocyanate onto a paper substrate.

It is also aobject to apply an isocyanate to paper in an nvironmentally safe manner.

se and other objects are obtained by the Summary of Invention The process of this invention is a process for treating a paper substrate with an isocyanate Gomprly the step of applying an isocyanate which does not contain water to the paper substrate by means of an electrostatic spraying device.

In a preferred embodiment, the process for treating a paper substrate with an isocyaate cepr-i-sethe step of applying an isocyanate which does not contain water to the paper substrate by means of an electrostatic spraying device which is comprised of an electrostatic sprayhead having a linear orifice, means for applying a first electrical potential to liquid isocyanate which emerges from the sprayhead, an electrode comprised of two mutually spaced, parallel arranged linear electrode elements, with one electrode element being mounted adjacent to one side of the sprayhead's orifice and the other element being mounted adjacent to the other side of the sprayhead's orifice, and means for applying a second electrical potential to the electrode such that an intense electrical field is developed between the emerging liquid and the electrode, the intensity ofthe field being sufficient to cause atomization of the emerging liquid, the electrode 4M A9 a core of conducting or semiconducting -3- S oS E T SUBSTITUTE SHEET _Y__Yi WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 material contained in a tubular sheath, caz-ator- L that the sheath has a wall and the volume resistivity of a section of the wall of said sheath which is 1 cm in length is within the range of 5 x 1011 to 5 x 1013 ohm cms.

The process of this invention provides light weight, uniform coatings of isocyanates on paper substrates and improves some of the physical properties of coated paper substrates, such as water resistance, wet strength and crush strength.

Detailed Description of Invention The process involves the electrostatic spraying of isocyanates onto paper substrates. The electrostatic spraying device employed to spray isocyanates onto paper substrates preferably comprises an electrostatic sprayhead having a linear orifice, means for applying a first electrical potential to liquid isocyanate which emerges from the sprayhead, an electrode comprised of two mutually spaced, parallel arranged linear electrode elements, with one electrode element being mounted adjacent to one side of the sprayhead's orifice and the other element being mounted adjacent to the other side of the sprayhead's orifice, and means for applying a second electrical potential to the electrode such that an intense electrical field is developed between the emerging liquid and the electrode, the intensity of the field being sufficient to cause atomization of the emerging liquid, the electrode comprising a core of conducting or semiconducting material contained in a tubular sheath, characterized in that the sheath has a wall and the volume resistivity of a section of the wall of said sheath which is 1 cm in length is within the range of 5 x 1011 to 5 x 1013 ohm cms. Such a device and its operating parameters have been fully described in United States Patent S-4i S ET I{ .SUBSTITUTE

SHEET

WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 No. 4854506, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

Generally, as the liquid isocyanate passes through the linear orifice of the device of U.S.

Patent No. 4854506, the isocyanate is charged at to 40 kV by the means for applying an electrical potential to the isocyanate. Preferably, the isocyanate is positively charged. Once the liquid isocyanate is charged, it breaks into droplets having diameters typically ranging from 40 to 150 microns in an electric field created between the charged liquid and the electrode comprised of the two linear electrode elements, which are usually charged between 10 kV and 25 kV and at the same polarity as the liquid. Generally, the voltage difference between the liquid isocyanate and the electrode comprised of the two linear electrode elements is between 15 and 30 kV. This voltage difference is called "stress." The isocyanates that are employed should have a viscosity in the range of 1 to 750 mPa.s, preferably in the range of 1 to 300, and a volume resistivity in the range of 1 x 106 to 1 x 10" ohm cms, preferably in the range of 5 x 106 to 5 x 109, and most preferably in the range of 5 x 107 to 5 x 109 ohm cms. Generally, the higher the viscosity of the isocyanate, the more difficult it is to apply the isocyanate.

Any isocyanate having one or more isocyanate groups and a viscosity and a resistivity between the above indicated limits can be employed. The isocyanates which may be used include aliphatic, cycloaliphatic, araliphatic and aromatic isocyanates, especially those that are liquid at room temperature.

Aromatic isocyanates, especially aromatic polyisocyanates, are preferred. Mixtures of isocyanates can be used and also isocyanates which have been modi- SUBSTITUTE

SHEET

WO 93/18228 PCr/EP93/00229 fied by the introduction of urethane, allophanate, urea, biuret, carbodiimide, uretonimine or isocyanurate residues.

Examples of suitable aromatic isocyanates include m- and p-phenylenediisocyanate, toluene-2,4and 2,6-diisocyanates, diphenylmethane-4,4'diisocyahate, diphenylmethane-2,4'-diisocyanate, chlorophenylene-2,4-diisocyanate, diphenylene-4,4'-diisocyanate, 4,4'-diisocyanate-3,3'-dimethyldiphenyl, 3methyldiphenylmethane-4,4'-diisocyanate and diphenyletherdiisocyanate and 2,4,6-triiso-cyanatotoluene and 2,4,4'-triisocyanatodiphenylether. There may be present mixtures of isocyanates for example a mixture of toluene diisocyanate isomers such as the commercially available mixtures of 2,4- and 2,6-isomers and also the mixture of di and higher isocyanates produced by phosgenation of aniline/formaldehyde condensates. Such mixtures are well known in the art and include the crude phosgenation products containing mixtures of methylene bridged polyphenylpolyisocyanates including diisocyanate, triisocyanate and higher polyisocyanates together with any phosgenation by-products.

Preferred compositions of the present invention are those wherein the isocyanate is an aromatic diisocyanate or polyisocyanate of higher functionality in particular crude mixtures of methylene bridged polyphenylpolyisocyanates containing diisocyanate, triisocyanate and higher functionality polyisocyanates. The methylene bridged polyphenylpolyisocyanates are sometimes referred to as polymeric methylene polyphenyldiisocyanate (MDI). Polyphenylpolyisocyanates are well known in the art and usually have an isocyanate functionality ranging from 2.0 to 3.0. They are prepared by phosgenation of corresponding mixtures of polyamines obtained by condensation of aniline and formaldehyde.

-6- SUBSTITUTE

SHEET

WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 Isocyanate-terminated prepolymers may also be employed and are prepared by reacting an excess of polyisocyanate with polyols, including aminated polyols or imines/enamines thereof, or polyamines.

Emulsifiable isocyanates may also be employed.

An emulsifiable isocyanate is an isocyanate/isocyanate prepolymer blend which is made by incorporating into an isocyanate a prepolymer formed by reacting monoalkyl ethers of polyalkylene glycols or polyester polyether glycols with a polyisocyanate to form an isocyanate terminated urethane adduct. Such blends are well known to be emulsifiable in water.

Suitable emulsifiable isocyanates and their preparation are described in United States Patent Nos.

3,996,154 and 4,505,778, which are incorporated herein by reference. Of the emulsifiable isocyanates, emulsifiable MDI is the most preferred.

The most preferred aromatic isocyanates are polymeric MDI, emulsifiable MDI, MDI variants, and mixtures thereof. Suitable MDI variants include compounds in which the MDI has been modified by the introduction of urethane, allophanate, urea, biuret, amide, carbodiimide, uretonimine and/or isocyanurate residues.

Examples of suitable aliphatic polyisocyanates include ethylene diisocyanate, 1,6-hexamethylene diisocyanate, isophorone diisocyanate, cyclohexane 1,4-diisocyanate, 4,4'-dicyclohexylmethane diisocyanate, saturated analogues of the above mentioned aromatic isocyanates, mixtures thereof and the like.

If the isocyanate to be used is a solid at the temperature of spraying, which temperature generally is 10 to 30 0 C and preferably 20 to 25°C, the isocyanate may be heated in order to liquefy it and the heated isocyanate can be sprayed. However, the isocyanate should generally not be heated to temper- ISUE -7i SUBSTITUTE SHEET WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 atures above 38 0 C before being sprayed. Preferably the isocyanate is liquid at the spraying temperature.

The liquid isocyanate is placed into a vessel from which the isocyanate can be pumped into the sprayhead of the electrostatic sprayer. Generally a hose connects the vessel and the electrostatic sprayer. The vessel is usually equipped with or connected to a means for pumping the isocyanate to the sprayhead at variable flowrates. The flowrate can vary from 0.5 to 150 g/minute/cm of nozzle width, and preferably is in the range of 1.5 to 75 g/minute/cm of nozzle width. The selected flbwrate will depend upon factors such as how much isocyanate is to be applied to the paper substrate and the speed at which the paper substrate is passing below the nozzle of the sprayer.

A wide variety of paper substrates can be treated according to the process of this invention. The process can be used to strengthen and size paper, corrugated paper containers, paper labels and paperboard. The process is especially useful in strengthening and sizing corrugated paper containers, such as containers that are likely to come into contact with moisture.

The paper substrate, when being sprayed, needs to be in contact with a conducting surface in order to prevent the paper substrate from building up a charge due to the deposition of charged isocyanate particles on the surface of the paper substrate. If a charge builds up on the surface of the paper substrate, the charge will repel charged isocyanate particles thereby leading to reduced transfer efficiencies and a non-uniform coating of isocyanate on the paper substrate. In practice the paper substrate is usually in contact with a metal roller over which the paper substrate passes. However, -8- SUBSTITUTE

SHEET

L I Lu c ii ICI11~- WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 when individual paper articles are being treated, they can be passed under the nozzle while in contact with a flat metal plate or sheet, such as a sheet of aluminum foil.

Preferably, the nozzle is wider than the width of the paper substrate being sprayed so as to insure that the entire surface of the substrate is coated with isocyanate. The distance of the nozzle from the surface of the paper substrate should be in the range of 7 to 23 cm. If the nozzle is too close, there can be sparking between the nozzle and the conducting surface in contact with the paper substrate. Also, a striped spray pattern may be produced on the substrate. On the other hand, if the distance is greater than 23 cm, the charged isocyanate particles tend to spread out and wander thereby lowering the transfer efficiency and making it difficult to have a uniform coating on the paper substrate.

It is important to insure that objects surrounding the nozzle of the spraying device not be too close to the nozzle. The reason is that surrounding objects that are too close to the nozzle will compete with the paper substrate for the charged isocyanate particles and thereby reduce transfer efficiencies. As a result, surrounding objects should generally be kept away from the nozzle at a distance at least four times the distance i between the nozzle and the paper substrate.

The paper substrate can be treated on one side or both sides. If treated on both sides, it is preferred for the isocyanate coating of the first treated side to be cured before treating the second side.

Since the isocyanates can be applied to paper substrates without being emulsified, it is not necessary to expose the substrate to a heat treatment -9- 1 WO 93/18228 PCT/EP93/00229 step in order to drive off water that is used to emulsify isocyanates. Nevertheless, it is preferred to include a heat treatment step in the process of this invention because heating the paper substrate after the isocyanate is applied promotes curing and can have a beneficial effect upon some of the physical properties of the coated paper substrate, such as crush strength. When a heat step is included, the paper substrate is usually exposed to a temperature in the range of 65 to 205 0 C for about 1 to seconds. The heat treatment of the paper substrate usually takes place in an oven through which the substrate is passed.

Although it is preferred to apply neat isocyanate to the paper substrates, additives which are compatible with the isocyanate and do not contain water can be mixed with the isocyanate prior to J applying the isocyanate to the paper substrate. For example, propylene carbonat-e can be added to the isocyanate to modify the viscosity of the isocyanate. However, too much propylene carbonate should not be added because the propylene carbonate tends to lower the resistivity of the isocyanate.

By using the process of this invention to treat paper substrates with isocyanates, the physical properties of the substrates can be improved. For example, the water resistance, the wet strength, and the crush strength of the substrates can be increased by using the process of this invention. The process also results in a uniform distribution of isocyanate on the paper substrates. Since charged particles are employed in the process and the particles seek to ground themselves instead of floating around in the atmosphere, the process results in greatly reduced levels of isocyanate in the atmosphere compared to conventional methods of applying isocyanates to paper substrates. Conventional spray SUBSTITUTE

SHEET

i r techniques release so .uch isocvanate into the atmosphere that the process -ust be enclosed with high air extraction.

The invention is illust..ted, but not limited, by the following examples.

Examoles 1. The electrostatic spraying device used was a device according to United States Patent No. 4854- 506 having a linear orifice and the following characteristics: the device was equipped with a linear nozzle spraying blade having a width of about cm (20 inches) the device was equipped with two field adjusting electrodes, which were two semi-conducting rods and which were placed parallel to the linear nozzle orifice at both sides.

Rubinate XI-241, which is polymeric MDI, is available from ICI Americas Inc or Rubicon Inc, Is a viscosity of 200 mPa.s, has a volume resistivity of 1 x 10 ohm cms and is liquid at room temperature, was placed into a pressure vessel which was connected to the electrostatic spraying device.

The liquid isocyanate was delivered to the device from the pressure vessel using air at about pounds/inch' Th-'air pressure was regulated by means of a pressure regulator so as to give a flow rate of 40 g/min or 0.8 g/minute/cm of nozzlewidth.

The pressure was about 12 pounds/inch 2 Y Once the linear nozzle spraying blade was completely wetted with isocyanate and the isocyanate was dripping off the blade, the power to the nozzle and the field adjusting electrodes was turned on so as to give a charge of -38 kV on the nozzle and a charge of -13 kV on the field adjustino electrodes.

-11- AMENDED SHEET -1 t NT 0 A 60 x 60 cm (2 x 2 ft) piece of 40 ib/l000ft 2 C0.'(~9 linerboard was then manually passed under the nozzle of the electrostatic spraying device. The nozzle was about 12.5 cm (5 inch) above and perpendicular to the paper. The paper was in contact with a steel plate while the paper passed beneath the nozzle to simulate paper going over a roller. After being coated on one side, the paper was allowed to cure for 24 hours at room temperature. It was then pazsed under the nozzle to coat the other side of the paper. The amount of isocyanate applied to the paper was 3.6% by weight calculated on the paper weight.

The physical properties of the treated paper were tested and are set forth in Table I below. The i treated paper had excellent water resistance and wet j strength compared to an untreated piece of paper and had improved crush strength as well.

2. Example 1 was repeated except that 10% by j weight of propylene carbonate was added to the polyi isocyanate. The amount of this composition applied to the paper calculated on the weight of paper was by weight. The physical properties of the paper were tested and the results are set forth in Table I below.

3. The electrostatic spraying device of el-ai 1 was used to treat paper on a conventional paper coating machine. A Carrier Ross roll coater machine was equipped with the electrostatic spraying device of claim 1 so that the paper would be sprayed prior to entering an oven. The nozzle was situated six inchesVdirect y above a metal roller so that the paper would be in contact with the metal roller at the. point where the isocyanat h s yed onto the paper. A roll of 651b/3000ftYbag aper comprised of percent recycled newspaper was placed on the Carrier Ross machine and fed underneath the nozzle -12- 3 i1

I

I I, of the spraying device at a rae of 230 feet per minute f. tv Pet, /A4Lt^ The isocyanate sprayed onto the paper was Rubinate XI-242, which is a water emulsifiable MDI, is available from ICI Americas Inc. and Rubicon Inc., has a viscosity of 250 mPa.s, and has a volume resistivity of 5 x 10' ohm cms. The charge on the isocyanate was -37.1 kV and the charge on the field adjusting electrodes was -18.1 kV. The flowrate of the isocvanate was 40 g/min or 0.8 g/minute/cm of nozzle width. After being sprayed with the isocyanate, the paper was run through a 121 0 C oven to dry the isocvanate. The amount of isocyanate applied to i the paper was about 1 percent by weight based upon the weight of the paper.

I

i After being treated with the isocyanate, the physical properties of the paper were tested. The paper had improved crush strength and exhibited a dramatic increase in water resistance and wet strength compared to an untreated piece of paper.

Ai 1 -13- .AMENDED SHEET

'I

i i;

Claims (8)

1. A process for treating a paper substrate with an isocyanate including the step of applying an isocyanate which does not contain water to the paper substrate by means of an electrostatic spraying device having a linear orifice, wherein said isocyar ate has a viscosity in the range of 1 to 750 mPa.s and a volume resistivity in the range of 1x106 to 1x10 ohm cms.

2. A process for treating a paper substrate with an isocyanate including the step of applying an isocyanate which does not contain water to the paper substrate by means o0 of an electrostatic spraying device which is comprised of an electrostatic sprayhead having a linear orifice, means for applying a first electrical potential to liquid isocyanate which emerges from the sprayhead, an electrode comprised of two mutually spaced, parallel arranged linear electrode elements, with one electrode element being mounted adjacent to one side of the sprayhead's orifice and the other element being mounted adjacent to the other side of the sprayhead's orifice, and means for applying a second electrical potential to the electrode such that an intense electrical field is developed S between the emerging liquid and the electrode, the intensity of the field being sufficient S to cause atomization of the emerging liquid, the electrode including a core of conducting or semiconducting material contained in a tubular sheath, wherein the 20 sheath has a wall and the volume resistivity of a section of the wall of said sheath which is 1 cm in length is within the range of 5x10 1 to 5x10 13 ohm cms.

3. The process according to claim -wherein the isocyanate has a viscosity in the range of 1 to 750 mPa.s and a volume resistivity in the range of 1x10 6 -1x10" ohm cms.

4. The process according to any one of claims 1 to 3 wherein the isocyanate has a 25 viscosity in the range of 1 to 300 and a volume resistivity in the range of 5x106 to 5x109. The process according to claim 4 wherein the isocyanate has a volume resistivity in the range of 5x10 7 to 5x10 8

6. The process according to any one of claims 1 to 5 wherein the isocyanate is applied to the paper substrate at a flow-rate of 0.5 to 150 g/minute/cm of nozzle width.

7. The process according to claim 6 wherein the flowrate is in the range of 1.5 to g/minute/cm of nozzle width.

8. The process of any one of claims 1 to 7 wherein the isocyanate is an aromatic Sisocyanate. nZ A WV44 A4079T.DOC -0 0(7 ~T 0/ SUBSTITUTE SHEET %!'iia ii' I,

16- 9. The process according to claim 8 wherein the isocyanate is a polymeric MDI, an emulsifiable MDI, an MDI variant or mixtures thereof. The process according to claim 9 wherein the isocyanate is an emulsifiable MDI. 11. The process of any one of claims 1 to 10 wherein after the isocyanate is applied to the paper substrate, the paper substrate is heated at a temperature in the range ot to 2050C. 12. A process according to claim 1 or claim 2 substantially as hereinbefore described with reference to any one of the examples. DATED: 1 March, 1996 PHILLIPS ORMONDE FITZPATRICK Attorneys for: IMPERIAL CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES PLC *1 C i, t' 0 t 6 I t t 4, jL( A\48079T.DOC -2- SUBSTITUTE SHEET Cx INTERNATIONAL SEARCH REPORT Inaaamai Apficadion No PCT/EP 93/00229 1. CLASSIFICATION OF SUBJECT MATIIR Of wroral ciasslfkatio symhois apply, indicate a&l) 6 Accoring to latersathhmej Patent Casificao (IPC) or to both National Clasifiaion and fpc Int.Cl. 5 D211-23/50; O21H19/24 UI. FIELDS SEARCHED Minimum Docummtatioo Semrdied7 Doaammutioo Searched other than Minimum Documentation to the Ficteat that such Documents aue Included in the Fields Searcheds I. DOCUMENTS CONSIDERED TO BE RELEVANT 9 category. Citation of Documnt I with indication, where aip riate, of the relevant passage$~ Relevant to Claim No.U Y EP,A,O 186 983 (IMPERIAL CHEMICAL 1-7 INDUSTRIES PLC) 9 July 1986 see the whole document US,A,4 854 506 cited in the application Y FR,A,1 156 723 (VEREINIGTE PAPIERWERKE 1-7 SCHICKEDANZ Co) May 1958 see the whole document A PATENT ABSTRACTS OF JAPAN 1,3-4, vol. 009, no. 160 (C-289)4 July 1985 8-10 JP,A,60 035 066 JIYOUETSU GIKEN KOGYO KK 22 February 1985 see abstract Special categories of cited docameam 10I later dooint published after the International filing date A' datmat ilin th of~ hic r priority date and not in tonflict with the appication but A' mde o eo dted to unnderstand the princile or theory undeuting the particols vaimina Er earler docmeet but pohished on or after the international 1P dcmt of particular relevace; the claime lnaetion filing daes cnam be cosidered novel or cannm be cnsdered to W' document Which my thmo doobtt on priorky claiws) or leuvl an inventive step which is cited to erslbi the puhicatem date of another 'Y domt of particalar rdevaanca the claimed inventin dtat"o of esae secidal res (AS emahid) gua be considered to ainveh an inventive step whe, the 0' domat reftng to inal dindum ere, c i ea or documem is a ieid With one or more Odha such dorn- ethemean am, socit cmbinationsa n hi to a persta skille q, imaeet published PH to the Interntina Aftg date hat in the art later tha the priority dote claime W doiaet member of the saneo patent family IV. CERTIFICATI1ON Date of the Actual Competio of the Istinnaeoal Search Date of Mail al this Interntional Search Report 17 MAY 1993 02. 04.93 International Searching Antheetty Signeeme of Anthoasil Officer EUROPEAN PATFJT OFFICE SONGY Odi11e fern PCTIUAJ2O fman ad tJamm INS K. lz IC SUBSTITUTE SHEET- 'I ANNEX TO THE INTERNATIONAL SEARCH REPORT ON INTERNATIONAL PATENT APPLICATION NO. EP SA 9300229 70706 Tbill wm Isi the Psant faniY meamer relating Co the patet doazaents ced in the above-meedioned inteienamamrc report The members awe as contained in the European Patent Office EDP flue on The European Patent Office. isn no way "iae for then partinlars which are merely given for the purpose 9f information. 17/05/93 Pat"~ &Domem Pubication Patent family Publication cited in mearch report doa meeTa daft EP-A-0186983 09-07-86 AU-B- 595170 29-03-90 AU-A- 5111085 26-06-86 CA-A- 1260697 26-09-89 JP-A- 61216759 26-09-86 US-A- 4854506 08-08-89 FR-A-1156723 None 0 Far 10flt utM Offs Ma OMI J1000 Of dou Fwps PaM Gfik, No. 12/22