JP5769462B2 - Decontamination condition determination method - Google Patents
Decontamination condition determination method Download PDFInfo
- Publication number
- JP5769462B2 JP5769462B2 JP2011065385A JP2011065385A JP5769462B2 JP 5769462 B2 JP5769462 B2 JP 5769462B2 JP 2011065385 A JP2011065385 A JP 2011065385A JP 2011065385 A JP2011065385 A JP 2011065385A JP 5769462 B2 JP5769462 B2 JP 5769462B2
- Authority
- JP
- Japan
- Prior art keywords
- decontamination
- temperature
- condition
- test
- humidity
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Active
Links
Landscapes
- Apparatus For Disinfection Or Sterilisation (AREA)
Description
本発明は、無菌室、クリーンルーム或いは病室などの室内に除染ガスを発生させて除染を行う際の適正な除染条件を決定する除染条件決定方法に関するものである。 The present invention relates to a decontamination condition determination method for determining an appropriate decontamination condition when decontamination is performed by generating a decontamination gas in a room such as an aseptic room, a clean room, or a hospital room.
医薬品或いは食品などを製造する製造現場、或いは、手術室などの医療現場においては、室内の無菌状態を維持することが重要である。特に医薬品製造の作業室である無菌室の除染においては、GMP(Good Manufacturing Practice)に即した高度な除染バリデーションを完了させる必要がある。 In a manufacturing site where pharmaceuticals or foods are manufactured, or in a medical site such as an operating room, it is important to maintain sterility in the room. In particular, in the decontamination of an aseptic room, which is a working room for pharmaceutical manufacturing, it is necessary to complete advanced decontamination validation in accordance with GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice).
近年、無菌室などの作業室(以下、除染対象室という)の除染には、人体に有害なホルマリンガスに替えて過酸化水素ガスが採用されつつある。この過酸化水素ガスは、強力な滅菌効果を有し、安価で入手しやすく、且つ、最終的には酸素と水に分解する環境に優しい除染ガスとして有効である。 In recent years, hydrogen peroxide gas is being used for decontamination of a working room such as an aseptic room (hereinafter referred to as a decontamination target room) instead of formalin gas harmful to the human body. This hydrogen peroxide gas has a strong sterilization effect, is inexpensive and easily available, and is effective as an environmentally friendly decontamination gas that eventually decomposes into oxygen and water.
この過酸化水素ガスによる除染効果は、除染対象部位の表面に凝縮する過酸化水素水の凝縮膜によるものであることが下記特許文献1に記載されている。従って、除染対象室の除染効果の完璧を図るには、過酸化水素ガスの供給量を多くして発生する過酸化水素水の凝縮膜を厚く或いは高濃度にすればよい。 It is described in the following Patent Document 1 that the decontamination effect by the hydrogen peroxide gas is due to a condensed film of hydrogen peroxide water condensed on the surface of the decontamination target site. Therefore, in order to achieve the perfect decontamination effect in the decontamination target chamber, the hydrogen peroxide solution condensed film generated by increasing the supply amount of the hydrogen peroxide gas may be made thick or high in concentration.
ところが、除染対象室に過剰量の過酸化水素ガスを供給すると過度な凝縮が起こり、除染対象室の内部に設置されている各種製造設備や精密測定機器或いは除染対象室の壁面などが発生した高濃度の過酸化水素水の凝縮膜により腐食されるという不具合が生じる。従って、除染ガスとして過酸化水素ガスを使用する場合には、従来の除染ガスに比べ、ガス供給量と除染効果の関係を考慮した高度な除染条件設定が特に重要となる。 However, if an excessive amount of hydrogen peroxide gas is supplied to the decontamination target chamber, excessive condensation occurs, and various manufacturing equipment and precision measuring equipment installed in the decontamination target chamber or the wall of the decontamination target chamber There is a problem that the high concentration hydrogen peroxide solution generated is corroded by the condensed film. Therefore, when hydrogen peroxide gas is used as the decontamination gas, it is particularly important to set advanced decontamination conditions in consideration of the relationship between the gas supply amount and the decontamination effect, as compared with the conventional decontamination gas.
この除染条件は、除染対象室の温度、湿度、ガス供給量(総投入量・投入速度・投入時間)などの多くのパラメータ(以下、これらを除染パラメータという)を組み合わせて設定され、上述の不具合が無く、且つ、高度な除染バリデーションを得るためには、除染効果を適正に評価し、その結果に基づいて適正な除染条件を決定することが重要となる。 This decontamination condition is set by combining a number of parameters (hereinafter referred to as decontamination parameters) such as temperature, humidity, gas supply amount (total input amount, input speed, input time) of the decontamination target chamber, In order to obtain the above decontamination validation without the above-mentioned problems, it is important to appropriately evaluate the decontamination effect and determine an appropriate decontamination condition based on the result.
ところで、無菌室などの除染対象室は、通常使用される際には空調設備を稼働して室内の温度及び湿度が制御されている。一方、室内に過酸化水素ガスを供給して室内の除染を行う際には、この空調設備を停止してから除染が開始される。従って、除染を開始する際の初期条件として、除染開始時の室内の温度及び湿度が除染パラメータとして設定される。 By the way, when the room to be decontaminated such as a sterile room is normally used, the air conditioner is operated to control the temperature and humidity in the room. On the other hand, when supplying the hydrogen peroxide gas into the room to perform decontamination in the room, the decontamination is started after the air conditioning equipment is stopped. Accordingly, the room temperature and humidity at the start of decontamination are set as decontamination parameters as initial conditions for starting decontamination.
ここで、除染対象室は、容積が大きく、室内形状も多様であることから、設置された空調設備の精度に限界があり、温度及び湿度の制御には一定の制御幅が生じる。従って、各除染パラメータを設定して1つの除染条件を構成した場合でも、実際の除染の際には、初期条件の温度及び湿度が一定の制御幅の中でその都度変動する。よって、高度な除染バリデーションを得るためには、初期条件の温度及び湿度が一定の制御幅の中で変動しても、当初予定していた十分な除染効果が発揮されなくてはならない。 Here, since the decontamination target chamber has a large volume and various indoor shapes, there is a limit to the accuracy of the installed air conditioning equipment, and a certain control range is generated for temperature and humidity control. Therefore, even when one decontamination condition is configured by setting each decontamination parameter, the temperature and humidity of the initial condition fluctuate each time within a certain control range during actual decontamination. Therefore, in order to obtain advanced decontamination validation, even if the temperature and humidity of the initial conditions fluctuate within a certain control range, the sufficient decontamination effect that was initially planned must be exhibited.
従って、1つの除染条件を実際に評価するには、温度、湿度以外の除染パラメータを固定した状態で、空調設備の温度制御幅及び湿度制御幅にそれぞれ対応した温度と湿度との組み合わせからなる複数の除染テストを実施する。その結果、いずれの温度と湿度との組み合わせにおいても十分な除染効果が発揮されることが確認された除染条件のみが有効な除染条件であると判定される。 Therefore, in order to actually evaluate one decontamination condition, with the decontamination parameters other than temperature and humidity being fixed, the temperature control range of the air conditioning equipment and the combination of temperature and humidity corresponding to the humidity control range respectively. Conduct multiple decontamination tests. As a result, it is determined that only decontamination conditions that have been confirmed to exhibit a sufficient decontamination effect at any combination of temperature and humidity are effective decontamination conditions.
しかし、1回の除染テストを行うには、煩雑で長時間の作業が必要となる。また、1つの除染条件を評価するには、上述のように空調設備の制御幅に対応した複数回のテストを要し膨大な時間と費用が必要になる。このことが、これまで除染条件を評価する際の重大な問題となっていた。 However, performing a single decontamination test requires complicated and long work. Further, in order to evaluate one decontamination condition, as described above, a plurality of tests corresponding to the control width of the air conditioning equipment are required, and enormous time and cost are required. This has been a serious problem in evaluating decontamination conditions.
更に、ある除染対象室にとって適正な除染条件を決定するには、まず、温度、湿度を含めた多くの除染パラメータを変化させ、それぞれを組み合わせた複数の除染条件を設定する。次に、個々の除染条件を評価して、要求される除染レベルを維持すると共に、過剰に過酸化水素ガスを供給することのない最も効率的な除染条件を決定する。 Furthermore, in order to determine a decontamination condition appropriate for a certain decontamination target room, first, a number of decontamination parameters including temperature and humidity are changed, and a plurality of decontamination conditions are set in combination with each other. Next, individual decontamination conditions are evaluated to determine the most efficient decontamination conditions that maintain the required decontamination level and do not supply excessive hydrogen peroxide gas.
このように、ある除染対象室に適正な除染条件を決定するには、可能性のある複数の除染条件を設定し、且つ、個々の除染条件に対して、それぞれ温度及び湿度の制御幅に対応した更に複数回の除染テストを実施しなければならない。 Thus, in order to determine appropriate decontamination conditions for a certain decontamination target room, a plurality of possible decontamination conditions are set, and for each decontamination condition, temperature and humidity are respectively set. Multiple decontamination tests corresponding to the control width must be carried out.
そこで、本発明は、上記の諸問題に対処して、過酸化水素ガスを採用して除染対象室の適正な除染条件を決定するに際し、膨大な時間と費用を要する除染テストの実施回数を軽減することを可能とし、複数の除染条件の中から効率的で高度な除染バリデーションを可能とする除染条件を決定することのできる除染条件決定方法を提供することを目的とする。 Therefore, the present invention addresses the above-mentioned problems and implements a decontamination test that requires enormous time and cost when adopting hydrogen peroxide gas to determine the appropriate decontamination conditions for the decontamination target room. The purpose of the present invention is to provide a decontamination condition determination method that can reduce the number of times and determine decontamination conditions that enable efficient and advanced decontamination validation from a plurality of decontamination conditions. To do.
上記課題の解決にあたり、本発明者らは、空調設備の温度制御幅及び湿度制御幅にそれぞれ対応した実際の除染テストを繰り返し、鋭意研究の結果、除染開始時点の除染対象室内の絶対湿度と除染効果との間に相関関係を見出して本発明の完成に至った。 In solving the above problems, the present inventors repeated actual decontamination tests corresponding to the temperature control range and humidity control range of the air conditioning equipment, respectively. A correlation was found between the humidity and the decontamination effect, and the present invention was completed.
即ち、本発明に係る除染条件決定方法は、請求項1の記載によれば、
温度湿度制御装置を備えた除染対象室に過酸化水素ガスを供給して当該除染対象室の内部を除染するために、温度パラメータ及び相対湿度パラメータを含む複数のパラメータの組み合わせからなる適正な除染条件を決定する除染条件決定方法であって、
上記除染条件を構成する上記複数のパラメータのうち少なくとも1つのパラメータを変化させて複数の除染条件を設定する除染条件設定工程と、
上記複数の除染条件に対して、それぞれ、上記除染対象室の所定位置に除染効果を判定するためのバイオロジカルインジケータを設置して各除染テストを実施する除染テスト実施工程と、
上記除染テスト実施工程後に上記バイオロジカルインジケータの判定結果から得られる各除染テストで達成された菌数の対数減少の値から当該除染テストの除染効果が予め定められた基準に適合するか否かを判定する除染効果判定工程と、
上記除染効果判定工程の結果から、上記除染対象室に対して適正な除染条件を決定する除染条件決定工程とを有しており、
上記除染テスト実施工程において、
除染テストを開始する際の初期条件としての温度パラメータの設定値をA(℃)、相対湿度パラメータの設定値をB(%)としたときに、上記温度湿度制御装置による制御が室内温度範囲〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)で制御可能であり、且つ、室内相対湿度範囲〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)で制御可能であれば、
上記室内温度範囲〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)と上記室内相対湿度範囲〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)との組み合わせにおいて、絶対湿度の値が最も小さくなる室内温度と室内相対湿度との組み合わせからなる1つの温度湿度条件のみを初期条件として採用し、上記除染対象室を当該温度湿度条件としてから上記温度湿度制御装置を停止して除染テストを開始することを特徴とする。
That is, according to the description of claim 1, the decontamination condition determination method according to the present invention,
In order to supply hydrogen peroxide gas to a decontamination target chamber equipped with a temperature / humidity control device and decontaminate the inside of the decontamination target chamber, an appropriate combination of a plurality of parameters including a temperature parameter and a relative humidity parameter A decontamination condition determination method for determining a decontamination condition,
A decontamination condition setting step of setting a plurality of decontamination conditions by changing at least one of the plurality of parameters constituting the decontamination conditions;
For each of the plurality of decontamination conditions, a decontamination test execution step for performing a decontamination test by installing a biological indicator for determining a decontamination effect at a predetermined position of the decontamination target chamber,
The decontamination effect of the decontamination test conforms to a predetermined standard from the logarithmic decrease in the number of bacteria achieved in each decontamination test obtained from the determination result of the biological indicator after the decontamination test execution step. A decontamination effect determination step for determining whether or not,
From the result of the decontamination effect determination step, it has a decontamination condition determination step for determining appropriate decontamination conditions for the decontamination target room,
In the decontamination test implementation process,
When the temperature parameter setting value is A (° C.) and the relative humidity parameter setting value is B (%) as an initial condition when starting the decontamination test, the temperature and humidity control device controls the indoor temperature range. [A-a1] (° C) to [A + a2] (° C) and can be controlled in the room relative humidity range [B-b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%)
In the combination of the indoor temperature range [A−a1] (° C.) to [A + a2] (° C.) and the indoor relative humidity range [B−b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%), the absolute humidity value is Only one temperature / humidity condition consisting of the combination of the lowest indoor temperature and room relative humidity is adopted as the initial condition, and the temperature / humidity control device is stopped after the temperature of the decontamination target room is set as the temperature / humidity condition. It is characterized by starting a test.
上記構成によれば、除染条件決定方法は、除染条件設定工程と除染テスト実施工程と除染効果判定工程と除染条件決定工程とを有している。除染条件設定工程は、除染対象室を過酸化水素ガスで除染するために各種除染パラメータを組み合わせ、適切と考えられる複数の除染条件を設定する。これら設定された除染条件は、続く除染テスト実施工程で実施され、いずれの除染条件が除染対象室に適切であるかが比べられる。 According to the above configuration, the decontamination condition determination method includes a decontamination condition setting process, a decontamination test execution process, a decontamination effect determination process, and a decontamination condition determination process. In the decontamination condition setting step, various decontamination parameters are combined to decontaminate the decontamination target chamber with hydrogen peroxide gas, and a plurality of decontamination conditions that are considered appropriate are set. These set decontamination conditions are implemented in the subsequent decontamination test execution process, and it is compared which decontamination conditions are appropriate for the decontamination target room.
ここで、これらの除染パラメータには、室内の温度と湿度、及び、過酸化水素ガスの供給速度と供給時間などがあり、これらを組み合わせることにより設定される。室内の温度と湿度は、除染テストの初期条件であり、供給速度と供給時間は、過酸化水素ガスの供給量に対応する。特に後者の過酸化水素ガスの供給速度と供給時間は、過酸化水素ガスを供給する室内除染装置によって制御される要素である。 Here, these decontamination parameters include the indoor temperature and humidity, the supply rate and supply time of the hydrogen peroxide gas, and are set by combining these. The room temperature and humidity are the initial conditions of the decontamination test, and the supply speed and supply time correspond to the supply amount of hydrogen peroxide gas. In particular, the supply speed and supply time of the latter hydrogen peroxide gas are factors controlled by the indoor decontamination apparatus that supplies the hydrogen peroxide gas.
除染テスト実施工程では、除染条件設定工程で設定された除染条件に従って、実際に除染対象室の除染を行う。除染テストは、求める除染レベルに合わせたバイオロジカルインジケータ(以下、BIという)による判定で行われる。 In the decontamination test execution process, the decontamination target room is actually decontaminated according to the decontamination conditions set in the decontamination condition setting process. The decontamination test is performed by determination using a biological indicator (hereinafter referred to as BI) that matches a desired decontamination level.
ここで、予め定められた基準とは、例えば、4〜6対数減少(ログ・リダクション)が発揮されるか否かをいう。例えば、6対数減少の除染レベルにおいては、使用する除染剤に最も耐性のある滅菌指標菌を106個有するBIを除染対象室の中の複数の箇所に設置して除染テストを行う。その後、このBIを回収、培養して、BIの滅菌指標菌が全到死した場合に6対数減少が達成されたと判定する。 Here, the predetermined reference means, for example, whether or not a 4 to 6 log reduction (log reduction) is exhibited. For example, at a decontamination level of 6 log reduction, BI having 10 6 sterilization indicator bacteria that are most resistant to the decontamination reagent to be used is installed at a plurality of locations in the decontamination target room. Do. Thereafter, this BI is collected and cultured, and it is determined that a 6 log reduction has been achieved when the sterilization indicator bacterium of the BI has completely died.
除染効果判定工程では、除染テストで回収したBIを所定の方法で培養し滅菌の状態を判定する。このようにして求められた除染テストの除染効果は、続く除染条件決定工程に供せられ、除染対象室に適切な除染条件を決定するために活用される。 In the decontamination effect determination step, the BI collected by the decontamination test is cultured by a predetermined method to determine the sterilization state. The decontamination effect of the decontamination test thus obtained is used in the subsequent decontamination condition determination step, and is used to determine the appropriate decontamination conditions for the decontamination target room.
除染条件決定工程では、BIの培養結果から判定された滅菌の状態と、除染パラメータのうち、過酸化水素ガスの供給速度及び供給時間から算出される過酸化水素ガスの総供給量を考慮して、過酸化水素ガスの過剰な供給とならず、且つ、作業上も効率的で除染効果の確実な除染条件が決定される。 In the decontamination condition determination step, the sterilization state determined from the culture result of BI and the total supply amount of hydrogen peroxide gas calculated from the supply rate and supply time of the hydrogen peroxide gas among the decontamination parameters are considered. As a result, a decontamination condition that is not excessive supply of hydrogen peroxide gas, is efficient in work, and has a decontamination effect is determined.
以上のようにして行う除染条件決定方法において、本発明の特徴とするところは、除染テスト実施工程にある。すなわち、除染条件の温度パラメータの設定値をA(℃)、相対湿度パラメータの設定値をB(%)としたときに、温度湿度制御装置の制御幅により、室内温度が〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)の範囲で変動し、且つ、室内相対湿度が〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)の範囲で変動する。 In the decontamination condition determination method performed as described above, a feature of the present invention resides in the decontamination test execution step. That is, when the setting value of the temperature parameter of the decontamination condition is A (° C.) and the setting value of the relative humidity parameter is B (%), the room temperature is [A-a1] depending on the control range of the temperature and humidity control device. The temperature fluctuates in the range of (° C.) to [A + a2] (° C.), and the indoor relative humidity fluctuates in the range of [B−b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%).
そこで、本発明においては、室内温度範囲〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)と上記室内相対湿度範囲〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)との組み合わせにおいて、複数の温度湿度条件における除染テストを実施することなく、絶対湿度の値が最も小さくなる温度と相対湿度との組み合わせの1つの温度湿度条件においてのみ除染テストを実施するようにする。 Therefore, in the present invention, in the combination of the indoor temperature range [A−a1] (° C.) to [A + a2] (° C.) and the indoor relative humidity range [B−b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%). Without performing the decontamination test under a plurality of temperature / humidity conditions , the decontamination test is performed only under one temperature / humidity condition of the combination of the temperature and the relative humidity at which the absolute humidity value becomes the smallest.
このことは、絶対湿度の値が最も小さい条件での除染テストが最も除染し辛い条件であることを理由とするものであり、絶対湿度がより大きい場合には、除染効果が大きくなることになる。従って、絶対湿度の値が最小の条件でのみ除染テストを実施することにより、最少の回数で正確な除染効果を達成することができる。 This is because the decontamination test under the condition where the absolute humidity value is the smallest is the most difficult condition for decontamination. When the absolute humidity is larger, the decontamination effect becomes larger. It will be. Therefore, by performing the decontamination test only under the condition where the absolute humidity value is the minimum, an accurate decontamination effect can be achieved with the minimum number of times.
よって、請求項1に記載の発明においては、過酸化水素ガスを採用して除染対象室の適正な除染条件を決定するに際し、膨大な時間と費用を要する除染テストの実施回数を軽減することを可能とし、複数の除染条件の中から効率的で高度な除染バリデーションを可能とする除染条件を決定することのできる除染条件決定方法を提供することができる。 Therefore, in the first aspect of the present invention, when hydrogen peroxide gas is used to determine the appropriate decontamination conditions for the decontamination target room, the number of decontamination tests that require enormous time and cost is reduced. Therefore, it is possible to provide a decontamination condition determination method capable of determining a decontamination condition that enables efficient and advanced decontamination validation from among a plurality of decontamination conditions.
以下、本発明に係る除染条件決定方法を説明するに当り、まず、本発明者らが実施した除染テストとその除染効果の解析について説明する。この除染テストは、空調設備による温度及び相対湿度の制御幅への対処を検討したものであり、温度、相対湿度及び曝露時間以外の除染パラメータを固定して実施した。
〔試験方法〕
(1)除染環境
空調設備を備えた容積60m3の除染対象室に対して、本発明者らの発明に係る室内除染装置(特開2009−273645号)を使用して、過酸化水素ガスによる除染テストを実施した。
Hereinafter, in describing the decontamination condition determination method according to the present invention, first, the decontamination test conducted by the present inventors and the analysis of the decontamination effect will be described. This decontamination test was conducted to deal with the control range of temperature and relative humidity by the air conditioning equipment, and was carried out with fixing decontamination parameters other than temperature, relative humidity and exposure time.
〔Test method〕
(1) Decontamination environment Using a room decontamination apparatus (Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2009-273645) according to the inventors' invention for a decontamination target room having a volume of 60 m 3 equipped with air conditioning equipment A decontamination test with hydrogen gas was performed.
(2)初期条件の設定
実際の除染テストは、除染対象室の空調設備を稼働して室内の温度及び相対湿度が安定した状態で空調設備を停止してから開始する。この空調設備を停止した時の室内の温度及び相対湿度の実測値を初期条件とした。この初期条件として、室内の温度を24℃、26℃、28℃の3水準とし、これらの室内の温度に対して、それぞれ、相対湿度条件を変化させて初期条件を設定した。今回の除染テストにおいては、相対湿度を34%〜64%の範囲で変化させた8組の初期条件を設定した(表1参照)。
(2) Setting of initial conditions The actual decontamination test is started after the air conditioning equipment in the room to be decontaminated is operated and the air conditioning equipment is stopped in a state where the indoor temperature and relative humidity are stable. The measured values of the indoor temperature and relative humidity when the air conditioning equipment was stopped were used as initial conditions. As the initial conditions, the room temperature was set to three levels of 24 ° C., 26 ° C., and 28 ° C., and the initial conditions were set by changing the relative humidity conditions for these room temperatures. In this decontamination test, eight sets of initial conditions were set in which the relative humidity was changed in the range of 34% to 64% (see Table 1).
この8組の初期条件に対して、それぞれ、以下の(3)〜(8)の手順に従って除染テストを実施した。 With respect to these eight sets of initial conditions, a decontamination test was performed according to the following procedures (3) to (8).
(3)BIの設置
除染対象室の所定位置に除染テストに必要な枚数の6対数減少用BIをセットした。
(3) Installation of BI The number of 6 log reduction BIs required for the decontamination test was set at a predetermined position in the decontamination target room.
(4)過酸化水素ガスの発生開始
室内の温度及び相対湿度の実測値が設定した初期条件に達したときに空調設備を停止し、過酸化水素ガスの発生を開始した。初期条件の温度及び相対湿度以外の除染パラメータのうち、過酸化水素ガスの供給量は、過酸化水素ガスの投入速度と投入時間で設定した。過酸化水素ガスの投入速度は、除染対象室に放出する過酸化水素ガスの単位時間当たりの発生量で設定し、具体的には上記過酸化水素ガス発生装置に滴下する35%過酸化水素水の滴下速度を1.5g/分として固定した。また、過酸化水素ガスの投入時間は、60分、120分、180分、240分、300分の5水準とした。
(4) Start of generation of hydrogen peroxide gas When the measured values of indoor temperature and relative humidity reached the initial conditions set, the air conditioning equipment was stopped and the generation of hydrogen peroxide gas was started. Of the decontamination parameters other than the initial conditions of temperature and relative humidity, the supply amount of the hydrogen peroxide gas was set by the input rate and the input time of the hydrogen peroxide gas. The injection rate of the hydrogen peroxide gas is set by the generation amount of the hydrogen peroxide gas released into the decontamination target room per unit time, and specifically, 35% hydrogen peroxide dropped on the hydrogen peroxide gas generator. The water dropping rate was fixed at 1.5 g / min. In addition, the hydrogen peroxide gas was charged at five levels of 60 minutes, 120 minutes, 180 minutes, 240 minutes, and 300 minutes.
(5)BIの回収
過酸化水素ガスの発生を開始したときから、60分毎にBIを回収した。従って、BIに対する過酸化水素ガスの曝露時間は、上記投入時間に対応して、60分、120分、180分、240分、300分の各時間であった。
(5) Recovery of BI BI was recovered every 60 minutes from the start of generation of hydrogen peroxide gas. Therefore, the exposure time of the hydrogen peroxide gas to BI was 60 minutes, 120 minutes, 180 minutes, 240 minutes, and 300 minutes corresponding to the charging time.
(6)BIの培養
回収した6対数減少用BIは、所定の方法で培養し滅菌の程度を判定した。
(6) Culture of BI The recovered 6-log reduction BI was cultured by a predetermined method to determine the degree of sterilization.
(7)室内のエアレーション
300分の投入時間を経過して全てのBIを回収した後、除染対象室の過酸化水素ガスを除去するために室内のエアレーションを360分行った。
(7) Indoor aeration After all the BIs were collected after 300 minutes had elapsed, indoor aeration was performed for 360 minutes in order to remove the hydrogen peroxide gas in the decontamination target chamber.
(8)BIの判定を基にしてD値を算出
除染効果の評価には、D値(Decimal reduction value)を採用した。D値とは、一定の除染条件下で初期の菌数を1/10に減少(90%死滅)させるのに必要な時間(分)を意味する。D値の計算には、上記6対数減少用BIの培養結果を用いたLSKM(Limited Spearman−karber Method)による方法を採用した。
〔試験結果の解析〕
上述の試験方法で行った8回の除染テストについて、初期条件と培養結果から算出したD値を表1に示す。
(8) Calculate D value based on determination of BI For evaluation of the decontamination effect, D value (Decimal reduction value) was adopted. The D value means the time (minutes) required to reduce the initial number of bacteria to 1/10 (90% death) under certain decontamination conditions. For the calculation of the D value, a method by LSKM (Limited Spearman-carber Method) using the culture result of the above 6 log reduction BI was adopted.
[Analysis of test results]
Table 1 shows the D values calculated from the initial conditions and the culture results for the eight decontamination tests performed by the above test method.
(1)温度とD値との関係
表1から求められた初期条件での室内の温度(℃)とD値(分)との関係を図1に示す。図1において、各測定点は、相対湿度によって大きく2つのグループに分けることができる。すなわち、相対湿度40%のグループT1と相対湿度60%のグループT2に分けられる。ここで、グループT1において、温度の増加に伴ってD値が徐々に小さな値をとる傾向が認められる。一方、グループT2においては、特に明確な相関関係が認められない。このことから、相対湿度に制御幅が存在する除染対象室の除染においては、室内の温度とD値との相関関係を見出すことはできなかった。
(1) Relationship Between Temperature and D Value FIG. 1 shows the relationship between the room temperature (° C.) and the D value (minute) under the initial conditions obtained from Table 1. In FIG. 1, each measurement point can be roughly divided into two groups according to relative humidity. That is, it is divided into a group T1 having a relative humidity of 40% and a group T2 having a relative humidity of 60%. Here, in the group T1, it is recognized that the D value tends to gradually become smaller as the temperature increases. On the other hand, in the group T2, a particularly clear correlation is not recognized. From this, in the decontamination of the decontamination target room having a control range in relative humidity, it was impossible to find a correlation between the room temperature and the D value.
(2)相対湿度とD値との関係
同じく、表1から求められた初期条件での室内の相対湿度(%)とD値(分)との関係を図2に示す。図2において、各測定点は、相対湿度によって大きく2つのグループに分けることができる。すなわち、相対湿度40%のグループH1と相対湿度60%のグループH2に分けられる。ここで、グループH1及びグループH2のいずれにおいても、相対湿度とD値との相関関係を見出すことはできなかった。
(2) Relationship Between Relative Humidity and D Value Similarly, FIG. 2 shows the relationship between indoor relative humidity (%) and D value (minutes) under the initial conditions obtained from Table 1. In FIG. 2, each measurement point can be roughly divided into two groups according to relative humidity. That is, it is divided into a group H1 having a relative humidity of 40% and a group H2 having a relative humidity of 60%. Here, in any of the group H1 and the group H2, no correlation between the relative humidity and the D value could be found.
(3)絶対湿度とD値との関係
次に、初期条件での温度及び相対湿度から湿り空気線図を用いて絶対湿度を求めた。ここでは、絶対湿度として容積絶対湿度(g/m3)を使用した。表2に求められた容積絶対湿度(g/m3)とD値(分)とを示す。
(3) Relationship between absolute humidity and D value Next, the absolute humidity was determined from the temperature and relative humidity under the initial conditions using a humid air diagram. Here, volume absolute humidity (g / m 3 ) was used as absolute humidity. Table 2 shows the absolute volumetric humidity (g / m 3 ) and the D value (min) determined.
以上のことから、空調設備の精度に限界があり、室内の温度及び相対湿度に一定の制御幅が存在する環境で、高度な除染バリデーションを完了させるためには、室内の絶対湿度に着目することが重要であることが分かる。
〔従来の除染条件決定方法〕
ここで、除染対象室の除染条件を決定するために従来行われていた除染条件決定方法の一例について説明する。例えば、除染パラメータとして、室内の温度、室内の相対湿度、過酸化水素ガスの投入速度、及び、過酸化水素ガスの投入時間をそれぞれ設定する。その他の条件は全て一定とする。
From the above, in order to complete advanced decontamination validation in an environment where the accuracy of air conditioning equipment is limited and there is a certain control range for indoor temperature and relative humidity, focus on the absolute humidity in the room. It turns out that is important.
[Conventional decontamination condition determination method]
Here, an example of a decontamination condition determination method that has been conventionally performed to determine the decontamination conditions of the decontamination target chamber will be described. For example, the room temperature, the room relative humidity, the hydrogen peroxide gas charging speed, and the hydrogen peroxide gas charging time are set as the decontamination parameters. All other conditions are constant.
上記除染パラメータのうち、過酸化水素ガスの投入時間は、他の除染パラメータが同じ場合には、同一環境での曝露時間を変化させることで対応可能である。従って、室内の温度、室内の相対湿度、過酸化水素ガスの投入速度が固定されている場合は、1回の除染テストを行えばよいと考えられる。 Among the decontamination parameters, the hydrogen peroxide gas charging time can be dealt with by changing the exposure time in the same environment when other decontamination parameters are the same. Therefore, if the room temperature, the room relative humidity, and the hydrogen peroxide gas charging speed are fixed, it is considered that a single decontamination test may be performed.
しかし、実際には上述のように、空調設備の制御幅に対応して温度及び相対湿度を組み合わせた複数回のテストを行わねばならない。更に、高度な除染バリデーションを完了させるためには、同一条件での除染テストを少なくとも3回実施することが求められる。 However, in practice, as described above, a plurality of tests in which temperature and relative humidity are combined in accordance with the control range of the air conditioning equipment must be performed. Furthermore, in order to complete advanced decontamination validation, it is required to perform decontamination tests under the same conditions at least three times.
仮に、室内の温度を21℃として制御幅が±2℃であり、一方、室内の相対湿度を45%として制御幅が±5%であるとする。この場合、従来の除染条件決定方法においては、少なくとも、(19℃・40%)、(19℃・50%)、(23℃・40%)、(23℃・50%)という4条件での除染テストの実施が必要であった。更に各条件に対して、それぞれ3回繰り返して実施すると、合計12回の除染テストが行われていた。 Assuming that the indoor temperature is 21 ° C. and the control width is ± 2 ° C., the indoor relative humidity is 45% and the control width is ± 5%. In this case, in the conventional decontamination condition determination method, at least four conditions of (19 ° C./40%), (19 ° C./50%), (23 ° C./40%), (23 ° C./50%) are used. It was necessary to conduct a decontamination test. Furthermore, when the test was repeated three times for each condition, a total of 12 decontamination tests were performed.
これに対して、本発明者らの上記知見によると、温度制御幅及び相対湿度制御幅の各組み合わせの中で絶対湿度の値が最も小さくなる温度と相対湿度の組み合わせのみで除染テストを行うことにより、複数の除染テストを行うことなく当該除染条件の評価が可能となる。上記の例においては、1つの条件で3回実施すればよく、従来12回を要していた除染テストの回数が3回となる。 On the other hand, according to the above findings of the present inventors, the decontamination test is performed only with the combination of the temperature and the relative humidity at which the absolute humidity value becomes the smallest among the combinations of the temperature control width and the relative humidity control width. Thus, the decontamination conditions can be evaluated without performing a plurality of decontamination tests. In the above example, it is sufficient to perform three times under one condition, and the number of decontamination tests that conventionally required 12 times is three.
以下、本発明に係る除染条件決定方法を実施形態に基づいて説明する。
〔本発明に係る実施形態〕
本実施形態においては、空調設備を備えた容積60m3の除染対象室に対して、本発明者らの発明に係る上記室内除染装置(特開2009−273645号)を設置し、過酸化水素ガスを用いて、当該除染対象室に適正な除染条件を決定した。
Hereinafter, a decontamination condition determination method according to the present invention will be described based on embodiments.
[Embodiment of the present invention]
In the present embodiment, the indoor decontamination apparatus (Japanese Patent Application Laid-Open No. 2009-273645) according to the inventors' invention is installed in a 60 m 3 decontamination target room equipped with air conditioning equipment, and peroxidation is performed. Appropriate decontamination conditions were determined for the decontamination target room using hydrogen gas.
(1)除染条件設定工程
除染パラメータは、初期条件としての室内の温度及び室内の相対湿度、並びに、過酸化水素ガス供給量としての投入速度及び投入時間を設定し、これらによる除染条件を表3に示す。
(1) Decontamination condition setting step The decontamination parameters set the room temperature and relative humidity in the room as initial conditions, and the charging speed and charging time as the hydrogen peroxide gas supply amount. Is shown in Table 3.
従って、本実施形態においては、上記従来の除染条件決定方法に従えば、(3設定条件×4温湿度条件)×3回=36回という膨大な回数の除染テストを要することとなり、従来では現実に実施することが不可能であった。 Therefore, in the present embodiment, according to the conventional decontamination condition determination method, a decontamination test of (3 setting conditions × 4 temperature / humidity conditions) × 3 times = 36 times is required. Then, it was impossible to actually carry out.
(2)除染テスト実施工程
表3に示すように温度には、21℃±2℃という制御幅があり、また、相対湿度には、45%±5%という制御幅が存在する。そこで、本実施形態においては、まず、温度19℃〜23℃及び相対湿度40%〜50%の各組み合わせに対して、湿り空気線図を用いて容積絶対湿度を求めた。その結果、温度19℃、相対湿度40%が最も絶対湿度の値が小さく、6.5g/m3であった。この結果、本実施形態においては、温度19℃、相対湿度40%という初期条件の下で、過酸化水素ガスの投入速度を変化させた3条件の除染テストを行うこととした。
(2) Decontamination test implementation process As shown in Table 3, the temperature has a control width of 21 ° C. ± 2 ° C., and the relative humidity has a control width of 45% ± 5%. Therefore, in the present embodiment, first, the absolute volume humidity was determined for each combination of a temperature of 19 ° C. to 23 ° C. and a relative humidity of 40% to 50% using a wet air diagram. As a result, the absolute humidity value was the smallest at a temperature of 19 ° C. and a relative humidity of 40%, which was 6.5 g / m 3 . As a result, in this embodiment, under the initial conditions of a temperature of 19 ° C. and a relative humidity of 40%, three conditions of decontamination tests were performed by changing the hydrogen peroxide gas input rate.
そこで、表3のNo.1の条件での除染テストを実施した。まず、除染効果の確認を行うために、除染対象室の40箇所に6対数減少用BIをセットした。 Therefore, No. in Table 3 The decontamination test was conducted under the condition of 1. First, in order to confirm the decontamination effect, 6 log reduction BIs were set at 40 locations in the decontamination target room.
この状態で、除染対象室の空調設備を稼働して室内の温度と相対湿度を調節した。そして、実測値で温度19℃、相対湿度40%となり安定した状態で空調設備を停止して除染テストを開始した。過酸化水素ガス発生装置に滴下する35%過酸化水素水の滴下速度は、表3に示すように1.0g/分であった。 In this state, the air conditioning equipment in the decontamination target room was operated to adjust the room temperature and relative humidity. The measured value was 19 ° C. and the relative humidity was 40%. The air conditioning equipment was stopped in a stable state, and the decontamination test was started. As shown in Table 3, the dropping rate of 35% hydrogen peroxide dropped to the hydrogen peroxide gas generator was 1.0 g / min.
過酸化水素ガスの発生を開始してから300分の投入時間が経過した後、過酸化水素ガスの供給を停止し、除染対象室の過酸化水素ガスを除去するために室内のエアレーションを360分行った。その後、全てのBIを回収して除染テストを終了した。 After 300 minutes have elapsed since the start of the generation of hydrogen peroxide gas, the supply of the hydrogen peroxide gas is stopped, and the indoor aeration is performed in order to remove the hydrogen peroxide gas in the decontamination target chamber. I went for a minute. Thereafter, all BIs were collected and the decontamination test was completed.
ここで、高度な除染バリデーションを完了させるためには、同一条件での除染テストを3回実施することが求められる。従って、上述と同様の除染テストを更に2回行った。 Here, in order to complete advanced decontamination validation, it is required to perform a decontamination test under the same conditions three times. Therefore, the same decontamination test as described above was further performed twice.
次に、同様にして、No.2の条件での除染テストを実施した。この除染テストにおいては、除染対象室内の温度と相対湿度を実測値で温度19℃、相対湿度40%とし、過酸化水素ガス発生装置に滴下する35%過酸化水素水の滴下速度は、表3に示すように1.5g/分であった。その他の条件は、No.1の除染テストと同様であった。また、高度な除染バリデーションを完了させるために同様の除染テストを更に2回行った。 Next, in the same manner, no. The decontamination test was conducted under the conditions of 2. In this decontamination test, the temperature and relative humidity in the room to be decontaminated are measured values of 19 ° C. and relative humidity 40%. As shown in Table 3, it was 1.5 g / min. The other conditions are No. This was the same as the 1 decontamination test. In addition, the same decontamination test was performed twice in order to complete advanced decontamination validation.
次に、同様にして、No.3の条件での除染テストを実施した。この除染テストにおいては、除染対象室内の温度と相対湿度を実測値で温度19℃、相対湿度40%とし、過酸化水素ガス発生装置に滴下する35%過酸化水素水の滴下速度は、表3に示すように2.0g/分であった。その他の条件は、No.1の除染テストと同様であった。また、高度な除染バリデーションを完了させるために同様の除染テストを更に2回行った。 Next, in the same manner, no. The decontamination test was conducted under the condition of 3. In this decontamination test, the temperature and relative humidity in the room to be decontaminated are actually measured at a temperature of 19 ° C. and a relative humidity of 40%, and the dropping rate of 35% hydrogen peroxide water dropped on the hydrogen peroxide gas generator is as follows: As shown in Table 3, it was 2.0 g / min. The other conditions are No. This was the same as the 1 decontamination test. In addition, the same decontamination test was performed twice in order to complete advanced decontamination validation.
(3)除染効果判定工程
各回の除染テストで回収したBIは、所定の方法で培養し滅菌の程度を判定した。本実施形態においては、使用したBIが6対数減少用のものであり、回収した全てのBIの滅菌指標菌が全到死した条件を6対数減少が達成されたものとして判定した。
(3) Decontamination effect determination step BI collected in each decontamination test was cultured by a predetermined method to determine the degree of sterilization. In the present embodiment, the used BI was for 6 log reduction, and the condition in which all of the collected sterilization indicator bacteria of all the BIs were completely killed was determined as having achieved 6 log reduction.
(4)除染条件決定工程
以上の結果から、No.1〜No.3の除染条件の中で本実施形態の除染対象室に対して、6対数減少の除染を保証する適切な除染条件を決定した。すなわち、6対数減少の除染効果を発揮する除染条件において、過酸化水素ガスの総投入量が最も少ない条件を選択した。この除染条件においては、仮に室内の温度が19℃〜23℃の範囲内で変動し、また、相対湿度が40%〜50%の範囲内で変動しても、必ず6対数減少の除染を保証することができる。
(4) Decontamination condition determination step From the above results, 1-No. Among the 3 decontamination conditions, appropriate decontamination conditions for decontamination with a 6 log reduction were determined for the decontamination target chamber of this embodiment. That is, in the decontamination conditions exhibiting the decontamination effect of 6 log reduction, the conditions with the smallest total amount of hydrogen peroxide gas were selected. Under these decontamination conditions, even if the room temperature fluctuates within the range of 19 ° C to 23 ° C, and the relative humidity fluctuates within the range of 40% to 50%, the decontamination always reduces by 6 logs. Can be guaranteed.
このように、従来では上述のように、少なくとも(3設定条件×4温湿度条件)×3回=36回の実施を必要とした除染テストの回数を3条件×3回=9回の実施で行うことができ、現実的なものとなった。このことにより、各除染条件に対して、6対数減少を保証できる過酸化水素ガスの供給量を考慮して、除染対象室の内部に設置されている各種製造設備や精密測定機器或いは除染対象室の壁面などが発生した高濃度の過酸化水素水の凝縮膜により腐食されるという不具合が生じる危険性の最も少ない除染条件を決定することができた。 Thus, conventionally, as described above, the number of decontamination tests requiring at least (3 setting conditions × 4 temperature / humidity conditions) × 3 times = 36 times is 3 conditions × 3 times = 9 times. It was possible to do it and became realistic. As a result, in consideration of the supply amount of hydrogen peroxide gas that can guarantee a 6 log reduction for each decontamination condition, various manufacturing facilities and precision measuring instruments installed in the decontamination target chamber or decontamination It was possible to determine the decontamination conditions with the least risk of causing the problem that the wall of the room to be dyed is corroded by the condensed film of high-concentration hydrogen peroxide.
よって、本実施形態においては、過酸化水素ガスを採用して除染対象室の適正な除染条件を決定するに際し、膨大な時間と費用を要する除染テストの実施回数を軽減することを可能とし、複数の除染条件の中から効率的で高度な除染バリデーションを可能とする除染条件を決定することのできる除染条件決定方法を提供することができる。 Therefore, in this embodiment, it is possible to reduce the number of decontamination tests that require enormous time and cost when using hydrogen peroxide gas to determine the proper decontamination conditions for the decontamination target room. In addition, it is possible to provide a decontamination condition determination method capable of determining a decontamination condition that enables efficient and advanced decontamination validation from a plurality of decontamination conditions.
Claims (1)
前記除染条件を構成する前記複数のパラメータのうち少なくとも1つのパラメータを変化させて複数の除染条件を設定する除染条件設定工程と、
前記複数の除染条件に対して、それぞれ、前記除染対象室の所定位置に除染効果を判定するためのバイオロジカルインジケータを設置して各除染テストを実施する除染テスト実施工程と、
前記除染テスト実施工程後に前記バイオロジカルインジケータの判定結果から得られる各除染テストで達成された菌数の対数減少の値から当該除染テストの除染効果が予め定められた基準に適合するか否かを判定する除染効果判定工程と、
前記除染効果判定工程の結果から、前記除染対象室に対して適正な除染条件を決定する除染条件決定工程とを有しており、
前記除染テスト実施工程において、
除染テストを開始する際の初期条件としての温度パラメータの設定値をA(℃)、相対湿度パラメータの設定値をB(%)としたときに、前記温度湿度制御装置による制御が室内温度範囲〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)で制御可能であり、且つ、室内相対湿度範囲〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)で制御可能であれば、
前記室内温度範囲〔A−a1〕(℃)乃至〔A+a2〕(℃)と前記室内相対湿度範囲〔B−b1〕(%)乃至〔B+b2〕(%)との組み合わせにおいて、絶対湿度の値が最も小さくなる室内温度と室内相対湿度との組み合わせからなる1つの温度湿度条件のみを初期条件として採用し、前記除染対象室を当該温度湿度条件としてから前記温度湿度制御装置を停止して除染テストを開始することを特徴とする除染条件決定方法。 In order to supply hydrogen peroxide gas to a decontamination target chamber equipped with a temperature / humidity control device and decontaminate the inside of the decontamination target chamber, an appropriate combination of a plurality of parameters including a temperature parameter and a relative humidity parameter A decontamination condition determination method for determining a decontamination condition,
A decontamination condition setting step of setting a plurality of decontamination conditions by changing at least one of the plurality of parameters constituting the decontamination conditions;
For each of the plurality of decontamination conditions, a decontamination test execution step for performing each decontamination test by installing a biological indicator for determining a decontamination effect at a predetermined position of the decontamination target chamber,
The decontamination effect of the decontamination test meets a predetermined standard from the logarithmic decrease in the number of bacteria achieved in each decontamination test obtained from the determination result of the biological indicator after the decontamination test execution step. A decontamination effect determination step for determining whether or not,
From the result of the decontamination effect determination step, it has a decontamination condition determination step for determining an appropriate decontamination condition for the decontamination target room,
In the decontamination test execution step,
When the temperature parameter setting value is A (° C.) and the relative humidity parameter setting value is B (%) as an initial condition when starting the decontamination test, the temperature and humidity control device controls the indoor temperature range. [A-a1] (° C) to [A + a2] (° C) and can be controlled in the room relative humidity range [B-b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%)
In combination with the indoor temperature range [A-a1] (℃) to [A + a2] (℃) and the indoor relative humidity range [B-b1] (%) to [B + b2] (%), absolute humidity value Only one temperature / humidity condition consisting of a combination of the room temperature and the room relative humidity at which the temperature becomes the smallest is adopted as the initial condition, and the temperature / humidity control device is stopped and removed after setting the room for decontamination as the temperature / humidity condition A method for determining decontamination conditions, characterized by starting a dye test.
Priority Applications (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| JP2011065385A JP5769462B2 (en) | 2011-03-24 | 2011-03-24 | Decontamination condition determination method |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| JP2011065385A JP5769462B2 (en) | 2011-03-24 | 2011-03-24 | Decontamination condition determination method |
Publications (2)
| Publication Number | Publication Date |
|---|---|
| JP2012200308A JP2012200308A (en) | 2012-10-22 |
| JP5769462B2 true JP5769462B2 (en) | 2015-08-26 |
Family
ID=47181910
Family Applications (1)
| Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| JP2011065385A Active JP5769462B2 (en) | 2011-03-24 | 2011-03-24 | Decontamination condition determination method |
Country Status (1)
| Country | Link |
|---|---|
| JP (1) | JP5769462B2 (en) |
Families Citing this family (3)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JP6111087B2 (en) * | 2013-02-15 | 2017-04-05 | 株式会社エアレックス | Decontamination system |
| JP2017012400A (en) * | 2015-06-30 | 2017-01-19 | 株式会社大林組 | Decontamination method and decontamination system |
| JP6610937B2 (en) * | 2015-11-09 | 2019-11-27 | 清水建設株式会社 | Drug effect prediction method |
Family Cites Families (8)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JPH0926172A (en) * | 1995-07-10 | 1997-01-28 | Sekisui Chem Co Ltd | Ventilation equipment |
| JP2981174B2 (en) * | 1995-09-08 | 1999-11-22 | 江本工業株式会社 | Building having moisture-proof function and moisture-proofing method of the building |
| US6895803B2 (en) * | 2000-10-20 | 2005-05-24 | Fisher & Paykel Healthcare Limited | Humidity sensor |
| JP3816351B2 (en) * | 2001-05-14 | 2006-08-30 | リンナイ株式会社 | Air conditioner for bathroom |
| US6752959B2 (en) * | 2001-10-05 | 2004-06-22 | Pepsico, Inc. | High-speed, low temperature sterilization and sanitization apparatus and method |
| JP4636382B2 (en) * | 2006-03-10 | 2011-02-23 | 株式会社日立プラントテクノロジー | Condensation prevention system for multi-storey building annex rooms |
| JP2010115451A (en) * | 2008-11-15 | 2010-05-27 | Earekkusu:Kk | Decontamination apparatus, method of determining decontamination condition in the same, and method of managing decontamination condition in the same |
| JP5452997B2 (en) * | 2009-07-02 | 2014-03-26 | 清水建設株式会社 | Indoor decontamination system |
-
2011
- 2011-03-24 JP JP2011065385A patent/JP5769462B2/en active Active
Also Published As
| Publication number | Publication date |
|---|---|
| JP2012200308A (en) | 2012-10-22 |
Similar Documents
| Publication | Publication Date | Title |
|---|---|---|
| Mendes et al. | Ethylene oxide sterilization of medical devices: a review | |
| JP5769462B2 (en) | Decontamination condition determination method | |
| JP6285060B1 (en) | Decontamination apparatus and decontamination method using the decontamination apparatus | |
| JP4936723B2 (en) | Method and apparatus for calculating the radiation dose distribution of a radiotherapy system for radiotherapy of an animal body | |
| EP2429944A4 (en) | NO2 GENERATION SYSTEM WITH HIGH CONCENTRATION AND HIGH-CONCENTRATION NO2 GENERATION METHOD USING GENERATION SYSTEM | |
| EP2830671B1 (en) | Gas sterilization/disinfection system and method for fluid conduits | |
| Zirkle et al. | Objective assessment of temporal bone drilling skills | |
| Chatzopoulos et al. | Large language models in periodontology: Assessing their performance in clinically relevant questions | |
| JP2017509408A (en) | A greatly enhanced decontamination method with hydrogen peroxide vaporized at low concentrations | |
| ATE499951T1 (en) | DEVICE AND METHOD FOR HUMIDIFYING A STERILIZATION CHAMBER | |
| CN101227931B (en) | Detection of sterilisation vapour condensation point | |
| Iwamura et al. | Confirmation of the sterilization effect using a high concentration of ozone gas for the bio-clean room | |
| FR2975890B1 (en) | SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR TRACEABILITY OF A SURGICAL INSTRUMENTATION SYSTEM | |
| US10815516B2 (en) | Method for establishing resistance characteristics of a biological indicator | |
| US20180200554A1 (en) | Ct value controller and anticancer agent degradation apparatus | |
| US20090119028A1 (en) | Apparatus and method for determining air-kerma rate | |
| JP7383864B1 (en) | Space decontamination method and space decontamination equipment | |
| WO2024053118A1 (en) | Space decontamination method and space decontamination apparatus | |
| Smith et al. | In vitro evaluation of cleaning efficacy of detergents recommended for use on dental instruments | |
| JP7737582B1 (en) | Space decontamination method and space decontamination device | |
| JP6610937B2 (en) | Drug effect prediction method | |
| BR102016025041B8 (en) | DENTAL TREATMENT OR EXAMINATION SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR OPERATING A DENTAL TREATMENT OR EXAMINATION SYSTEM | |
| Qureshi et al. | Method development and validation of total viable count using specified techniques and performance characteristics of ISO/IEC 17025: 2017 in microbiological samples | |
| Shu et al. | Surgical protocol affecting robotic implant accuracy: Ex-vivo study | |
| Clifford | Residual Moisture Following Endoscope Reprocessing and Drying |
Legal Events
| Date | Code | Title | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| A621 | Written request for application examination |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A621 Effective date: 20131224 |
|
| A977 | Report on retrieval |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A971007 Effective date: 20140905 |
|
| A131 | Notification of reasons for refusal |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A131 Effective date: 20140916 |
|
| A521 | Request for written amendment filed |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A523 Effective date: 20141113 |
|
| A131 | Notification of reasons for refusal |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A131 Effective date: 20150331 |
|
| A521 | Request for written amendment filed |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A523 Effective date: 20150501 |
|
| TRDD | Decision of grant or rejection written | ||
| A01 | Written decision to grant a patent or to grant a registration (utility model) |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A01 Effective date: 20150602 |
|
| A61 | First payment of annual fees (during grant procedure) |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: A61 Effective date: 20150623 |
|
| R150 | Certificate of patent or registration of utility model |
Ref document number: 5769462 Country of ref document: JP Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R150 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |
|
| R250 | Receipt of annual fees |
Free format text: JAPANESE INTERMEDIATE CODE: R250 |